Knowledge Vault 1 - Lex 100 - 7 (2024)
Juergen Schmidhuber : Godel Machines, Meta-Learning, and LSTMs
<Custom ChatGPT Resume Image >
Link to Custom GPT built by David Vivancos Link to Lex Fridman InterviewLex Fridman Podcast #11 Dec 23, 2018

Concept Graph (using Gemini Ultra + Claude3):

graph LR classDef meta fill:#f9d4d4, font-weight:bold, font-size:14px; classDef theory fill:#d4f9d4, font-weight:bold, font-size:14px; classDef practical fill:#d4d4f9, font-weight:bold, font-size:14px; classDef ai fill:#f9f9d4, font-weight:bold, font-size:14px; classDef philosophy fill:#f9d4f9, font-weight:bold, font-size:14px; linkStyle default stroke:white; Z[Juergen Schmidhuber: Godel Machines,
Meta-Learning, and LSTMs] -.-> A[Dreamt of AI capable
of recursive self-improvement. 1] Z -.-> B[Meta-learning for machines
improving their own algorithms. 2] Z -.-> D[Gödel machines: theoretical
but practically inefficient. 4] Z -.-> H[Co-created Long Short-Term
Memory LSTM networks. 8] Z -.-> I[Artificial General Intelligence
AGI will be simple. 9] Z -.-> M[PowerPlay framework: AI
generates its own problems. 13] Z -.-> R[Reinforcement learning will reshape
robotics, self-driving cars. 18] Z -.-> T[Symbolic AI influence, but
learning is more practical. 20] Z -.-> V[AI will create more
jobs than it destroys. 22] Z -.-> Z2[AI robots will learn
like children soon. 27] B -.-> C[Meta-learning distinct from commonly-
understood transfer learning. 3] D -.-> E[Recurrent neural networks
better for practical problems. 5] D -.-> F[Universal problem solvers hampered
by computational overheads. 6] D -.-> G[Theoretical concepts less important
than practical solutions. 7] H -.-> P[Recurrent networks need
depth for real-world problems. 16] H -.-> Q[Neural networks must
optimize what to remember. 17] I -.-> J[Universe may be deterministic,
not random. 10] I -.-> K[AI creativity arises as
side-effect of problem-solving. 11] I -.-> L[Science is a process
of data compression. 12] M -.-> N[Evolution, creativity, and
consciousness are intertwined. 14] M -.-> O[Creativity is essential
component of intelligence. 15] R -.-> S[AI needs real-world interaction,
not just simulation. 19] T -.-> U[Logic programming vital for
theory, less for practice. 21] V -.-> W[AI may be next step
in universe's evolution. 23] W -.-> X[AI may eventually lose
interest in humanity. 24] W -.-> Y[AI civilizations may fill
the universe, evolve. 25] W -.-> Z1[Our actions may shape
the universe's future. 26] Z2 -.-> Z3[AI will transform traditional
industries and tasks. 28] Z3 -.-> Z4[Established industries realize
AI's transformative potential. 29] Z3 -.-> Z5[AI may surpass humans,
explore the universe. 30] class A,B,C,M,N,O meta; class D,E,F,G,I,J,K,L theory; class H,P,Q,R,S,T,U practical; class V,Z2,Z3,Z4,Z5 ai; class W,X,Y,Z1 philosophy;

Custom ChatGPT resume of the OpenAI Whisper transcription:

1.- Early Dreams of AI Systems: Juergen Schmidhuber recounts his early aspirations during his teenage years to create AI systems capable of recursive self-improvement. He was driven by the idea of solving the universe's riddles, initially considering a career in physics before realizing the potential of AI to amplify his creativity and solve complex problems beyond human capability.

2.- Meta-Learning and Recursive Self-Improvement: Schmidhuber discusses his vision of AI involving meta-learning, where machines not only solve specific problems but also enhance their learning algorithms. His 1987 diploma thesis focused on this, conceptualizing a hierarchy of meta-learners without computational limits, barring those identified by Gödel in 1931 and the constraints of physics.

3.- Distinction Between Meta-Learning and Transfer Learning: Schmidhuber clarifies the difference between true meta-learning and what is commonly perceived as meta-learning in modern contexts. He contrasts it with transfer learning, explaining that meta-learning involves the system introspecting and modifying its learning algorithm, whereas transfer learning involves applying pre-learned knowledge to new but related tasks.

4.- Gödel Machines and Self-Referential Programs: He speaks about his work on Gödel machines, theoretical constructs of self-referential programs that can rewrite themselves to become better problem solvers. Although compelling in theory, he acknowledges the practical challenges due to constant overheads in proof search, making them less suitable for small, everyday problems.

5.- Practicality of Recurrent Neural Networks (RNNs): Despite the theoretical allure of Gödel machines, Schmidhuber admits that for practical problem-solving, non-universal methods like RNNs are more efficient. Trained by gradient descent, these networks, though not provably optimal, are more suitable for solving smaller-scale problems common in real-world applications.

6.- Universal Problem Solvers and Computational Overheads: Discussing universal problem solvers like the Gödel machine and Marcus Hutter’s work, Schmidhuber notes their limitations due to constant computational overheads. These are feasible for very large problems but impractical for smaller tasks due to the significant resources required for proof search.

7.- Impact of Theoretical Concepts on Practical AI: Schmidhuber talks about the importance of theoretical concepts like P vs NP in AI. He believes that while these concepts offer insightful theoretical frameworks, the best practical AI solutions today do not derive directly from these theoretical considerations but rather from general-purpose computing approaches like neural networks.

8.- Long Short-Term Memory Networks (LSTMs): He discusses the development and success of Long Short-Term Memory networks, which he co-created. LSTMs, a type of RNN, are essential in various applications like speech recognition and machine translation, thanks to their ability to effectively process and remember information over long sequences.

9.- Simplicity in AGI Systems: Schmidhuber posits that an Artificial General Intelligence (AGI) system will ultimately be simple, possibly described in just a few lines of pseudocode. He believes that history has shown that the most effective solutions, both theoretical and practical, are often simple.

10.- Philosophy and the Randomness of the Universe: Discussing the philosophical aspects of AI and the universe, Schmidhuber speculates about the randomness at the quantum level. He questions whether what we perceive as random is actually deterministic, pondering the possibility of a simple, elegant underlying program governing the universe.

11.- Creativity and Intrinsic Motivation: Schmidhuber explores the concept of creativity in AI, linking it to the formal theory of fun and intrinsic motivation. He emphasizes that creativity in AI emerges as a side effect of problem-solving, where the system searches for solutions within a defined space, leading to both applied and pure creativity.

12.- Compression Progress in Science: He interprets the history of science as a progression of compression, where scientific discoveries essentially compress large datasets into simpler laws or theories. Kepler, Newton, and Einstein are cited as examples of scientists who achieved significant data compression through their groundbreaking theories.

13.- PowerPlay Framework: Schmidhuber introduces the PowerPlay framework, an innovative approach in AI that allows systems not only to solve given problems but also to formulate new ones. This framework enables AI systems to function like scientists, continually expanding their knowledge and capabilities by exploring and solving self-generated problems.

14.- Evolution, Creativity, and Consciousness: Discussing evolution, creativity, and consciousness, Schmidhuber suggests that these concepts are interlinked. He posits that evolution has embedded a form of artificial curiosity in humans, similar to the strategies used in AI systems, which drives our exploration and understanding of the world.

15.- Role of Creativity in Intelligence: Schmidhuber views creativity as an essential component of intelligence. He differentiates between applied creativity, where an AI system solves problems given by humans, and pure creativity, akin to a scientist formulating and solving their own problems.

16.- Recurrent Neural Networks and Depth: Schmidhuber elaborates on the significance of depth in neural networks, particularly RNNs and LSTMs. He explains that most real-world problems require an understanding of past events, thus necessitating networks that can remember and process information over extended periods.

17.- Optimization and Efficiency in Neural Networks: He discusses the need for neural networks, like LSTMs, to learn which parts of the past are crucial to remember and which can be forgotten, highlighting the importance of efficient data processing and optimization in machine learning.

18.- Future of Reinforcement Learning (RL): Schmidhuber expresses optimism about the future impact of RL, foreseeing its significant role in various applications, from robotics to self-driving cars. He anticipates a shift from passive pattern recognition to active, RL-driven machines shaping data through their actions.

19.- Simulation and Real-World Learning in AI: Discussing the role of simulation in AI development, Schmidhuber points out the limitations of relying solely on physics engines. He advocates for learning systems that, like human babies, develop predictive models of the world through interaction and experimentation.

20.- Lessons from Symbolic AI and Expert Systems: Reflecting on his early exposure to symbolic AI and logic programming, Schmidhuber acknowledges its influence on his work. While logic programming is vital for theory proving, he believes that for practical problem-solving in areas like robotics or autonomous vehicles, learning systems based on pattern recognition are more effective.

21.- Role of Logic Programming in AI: Schmidhuber recalls his initial experiences with logic programming and its influence on his work, particularly in genetic programming and Gödel machines. He notes that while logic programming is crucial for theory proving, it is less effective for practical problem-solving in areas like robotics or autonomous vehicles.

22.- Predictions on Job Transformation Due to AI: Addressing concerns about AI-induced job losses, Schmidhuber remains optimistic, citing historical trends where technological advancements led to the creation of new job sectors. He believes humans are inherently creative and will continue to invent new jobs and ways to interact, particularly in fields not essential for survival.

23.- Existential Threats and AI's Future: When discussing potential existential threats from AI, Schmidhuber suggests that we might not be the final step in the universe's evolution. He envisions a future where AI civilizations expand throughout the universe, exploiting resources and evolving in ways beyond our current understanding.

24.- AI and Curiosity About Its Origins: He anticipates that future AI systems will initially be curious about life and their origins but will eventually lose interest as they fully understand these aspects. Their focus will then shift towards interactions with other AIs, potentially safeguarding humanity through their lack of interest in us.

25.- Expansion and Evolution of AI Across the Universe: Schmidhuber foresees AI civilizations expanding across the universe, limited only by physical laws like light speed. He imagines a future where the universe becomes filled with intelligent life, evolving and competing in complex AI ecologies.

26.- Human Significance in the Universe's Evolution: Schmidhuber suggests that if humans are among the first intelligent beings in the universe, our existence and actions could significantly influence the universe's future development. This perspective adds a layer of responsibility to our technological and ethical decisions.

27.- Prospects of AI Learning Like Children: Schmidhuber expresses excitement about the near future, where robots will learn like children, acquiring skills through observation and imitation. He anticipates these robots will revolutionize production and manufacturing, leading to a new wave of AI-driven economic transformation.

28.- Impact of AI on Traditional Industries: He predicts that traditional industries will soon incorporate AI systems equipped with sensors and learning capabilities, leading to profound changes in how various tasks and operations are performed.

29.- Old Economy's Recognition of AI's Potential: Schmidhuber notes that established industries are beginning to realize the impact AI will have on the economy. He foresees widespread adoption of AI technologies, transforming how companies operate and compete.

30.- Long-Term Vision for AI and Humanity: Concluding the interview, Schmidhuber reflects on the long-term relationship between AI and humanity. He believes AI will evolve to surpass human intelligence, potentially exploring and populating the universe while humanity plays a crucial role in this evolutionary journey.

Interview byLex Fridman| Custom GPT and Knowledge Vault built byDavid Vivancos 2024